Thursday, May 23, 2013
image image
Monday, December 19, 2011

NRI Indian community - missing in action from the lives of new Indian students in US

By Siddarth Sehgal

MazeIt’s a tricky question, whenever I think about the help and assistance that is available to new students from India from the Indian community here in United States, rarely anything comes into my mind that I can credit to the Indian community and by that I mean Indians who are already settled here with family, job and businesses.

The only support system I had was the help I got from the Indian students already living here but as I said in the beginning it’s a tricky question because everyone has their own experience, each student has his own story to tell whether good or bad.  But on a general level and the students that I have met and known over the years didn’t get any support from the Indian community.

Shakespeare once quoted that expectation is the root of all heartache but I really don’t think that a new comer to United States would have big expectations with the NRI community, of course that’s just me but from apartments to food, from transportation to telephone all kinds of basic sustainable requirements are provided for by other Indian students. The things where a new student should definitely get support from the Indian community is the guidance on how things work in US, the cultural differences, community involvement and other crucial information. I was lucky to have the guidance of few kindhearted Indians who shared their valuable experience with me which helped me a lot in my academic and professional endeavor but not every Indian student enjoys such privileges and there are several reasons for that.

Most of the time students don’t know whom to ask for help and great many times the Indians who are well settled here don’t bother to reach out to their struggling young compatriots. I have seen and experienced this wide gap firsthand in Pelham temple when I was doing a signature campaign in support of India against corruption movement. It was only after I was shown the door, I was told about the politics that has divided the seemingly unified community.

Even here at UAB (University of Alabama at Birmingham), there are two types of Indian students. One who came from India and the other who are of Indian origin but are born and raised in United States, popularly known as ABCDs. Though, I have good friends in both these groups but very rarely I have seen people in both these categories interacting with each other. When I was starting my journey at UAB, I didn’t have any ABCD friend. My roommates told me that most of the ABCD students maintain distance from other Indian students. When I asked the reason behind this rift, I didn’t get any satisfactory answer and even today, it’s somewhat of a mystery to me.

But the story didn’t end there because then we have subdivisions in Indian students itself. There are groups of Marathis, Guajaratis, Bengalis, Tamils and God knows how many other different clusters that live on loosely exclusive bases. Student from one state usually live together and being from a Hindi-speaking state in India, I had a really hard time adjusting with my roommates; I was always on the sidelines. Many times, these students get help from their paternal state cultural groups like Bengali, Tamil or Telegu organizations. I have many Telugu and Bengali friends who would often visit their respective community gatherings and festive celebrations but rarely people from other states attend these meetings. Either they are not invited or they have an organization of their own.

It was a bit amusing, ironical and pleasant fact that I never had anything else to identify with other than my country. There is a saying that society doesn’t owe us anything and that indeed is true, but from the lessons I have learned here in United States I think, things can be changed a bit but as I said earlier, that’s just my viewpoint. After all, we all fight our own battles.


Other posts by Siddarth Sehgal:

Siddarth Sehgal frequently writes in Pravasi Herald on international issues, politics and human rights.

Print Friendly Version

(Permalink)

Sunil Sane
Hoover
01/03/2012
01:32 pm

Siddarth, it’s always easy to blame others. Your conclusion is one sided. Have you found out from ICAB or did any research before writing the article? Traditional wisdom says, always try to find out the other side of the story too. You can’t clap with one hand. There was a time when students who came to UAB mingled with local Indian community and community helped them. But over the period of time, especially in last 10 years, things have changed. Again good things will suffer because of bad ones. That’s what happened. More students were self centered and wanted us to help them, without offering any participation from their side. Co-operation is 2 way street. When we came to USA, we did not have any help and realizing that, we helped many students and others, only to repent later. There are many stories from NRIs, when you hear then you will know why NRIs are not eager to help students now. Tell me how many students have attended ICAB events last year or even tried to find out that there’s anything going on? You have no right to even utter a word about our kids who are born here. The answer to this mystery, is in your article itself except, it’s not based on the language. Here’s what you are saying “Student from one state usually live together and being from a Hindi-speaking state in India, I had a really hard time adjusting with my roommates; I was always on the sidelines…”. Here we are talking about countries. Because their parents are from India does not make them Indian & one should not assume that they must interact with Indian students.
ICAB has always tried to wipe the state and language barriers and especially in last few years, we have tried every weapon in our arsenal to bridge the gap. But as I said, it’s not a one way street.

Desi
Ohio
12/22/2011
04:45 pm

@Chiman Delwadia:  No one can help UAB students, you have to serve them.  Comprender?  Maybe you do and will, but Siddharth is right.  That is the Indian way.

Chiman Delwadia
Birmingham AL
12/20/2011
08:30 pm

Sidharth
I am sorry to hear that you are disappointed with the local Indian community. I know, Indian Cultural Association of Birmingham (ICAB) tried to help new students coming from India. We had organized welcoming dinners for new students many times in the past. ICAB committee had a standing instruction to UAB student organizations to contact us anytime they need any help. My experience is that we had a very poor response from the student organizations.
As an Indian community, we are ready to help. Please remove your misconception and try again.
Thanks
Chiman Delwadia
257-7331(h)
.(JavaScript must be enabled to view this email address)

Monika Mehrotra
Birmingham,AL
12/20/2011
02:18 pm

This is sad but true.

Commenting is not available in this weblog entry.